- Both run an autonomous AI chatter on OnlyFans: Hugo in OnlyX, Izzy in Supercreator.
- OnlyX charges nothing for the CRM and 10% of the payout on PPVs Hugo sells. Supercreator's Super AI is a fee per account that rises with earnings, plus 5% of AI net sales, plus extra AI messages beyond the credits it includes.
- For one creator whose AI sells $2,000 a month: $160 on OnlyX, $199 on Super AI before extra messages.
- Supercreator has copilots for human chatters and a free CRM Lite for up to 10 accounts. OnlyX has per-fan pricing above your floor, Telegram and Fanvue, and a measured median reply of 23 seconds.
- On the score in our 2026 comparison, weighted toward how much selling the AI does on its own: OnlyX + Hugo 87/100, Supercreator + Izzy 38/100. Scored by OnlyX from public information; the method is published there.
We build OnlyX, so this is one vendor comparing itself with another. Every Supercreator fact below comes from Supercreator's own pages, read on 26 October 2026; where it does not say, we write that. Check the parts that matter to you on their pages too.
At a glance
| OnlyX + Hugo | Supercreator + Izzy | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | A free CRM with Hugo, an autonomous AI chatter | A CRM with Izzy, an autonomous AI chatter, on its Super AI plan |
| Platforms | OnlyFans and Telegram; Fanvue through its official API (new, October 2026) | OnlyFans |
| CRM price | Free for every creator and every team seat | CRM Lite free for up to 10 accounts, without AI; CRM Premium from $15 per account a month |
| AI price | 10% of the payout on PPVs Hugo sold and the fan unlocked. No per-message charge | From $99 per account a month, rising with earnings, + 5% of AI net sales. AI messages beyond the included credits cost up to 3¢ each |
| How the AI works | Autonomous. Your team takes any chat back in one click | Autonomous, with live monitoring. CRM Premium also has reply, inbox and pricing copilots |
| What it sells | Only content you have mapped; the server checks every pick | Bundles from a catalog of at least ten, sent through scripts |
| Prices | Per fan, from what he has paid before; never below your floor | Each bundle has a minimum price; guardrails can block prices; a Pricing Copilot |
| What a fan already owns | Never re-offers a level the fan bought, even one a human sold him | Says no fan receives a script with content he already bought |
| Fan memory | Notes on both sides, promises with dates, and a plan written from the whole chat | Reads the whole chat; sees spend, tips, buy rate, PPV history, lists and team notes |
| Follow-ups | Timed to when each fan is around; two a day by default; stand down when anyone writes | Bumps, AutoFollower for expired fans, message flows |
| Hand-over to people | About 35 situations per creator; minors and self-harm always go to a person | Izzy flags chats for human review; watch every AI message live |
| Languages | The fan's language, kept for the whole chat; native-reviewed FR, ES, PT, DE, HR/SR | Languages added to the creator's bio; inbox auto-translation |
| Published reply speed | Median 23 seconds, 85% within 40 seconds (the 7 days to 26 October 2026) | No figure: "instantly", with "natural timing" |
| How it connects | You sign in, the creator signs in herself in the OnlyX Login app, or through her phone | Desktop, mobile and web apps; says it never collects or stores login credentials |
What does each cost for 1, 5 and 20 creators?
Our example: each account earns $6,000 a month, which puts it in Supercreator's $1,000 to $15,000 band, where Super AI is $119 a month (read with the earnings slider on 11 October 2026; the page opens on $99, the price of its lowest band). The AI sells $2,000 of PPVs a month per account, and OnlyFans keeps 20%, leaving $1,600 of payout. Supercreator does not define "AI net sales", so we read it as the payout, the cheaper reading for Supercreator.
| Creators, AI sells $2,000 each | OnlyX | Supercreator Super AI, before extra messages |
|---|---|---|
| 1 creator, a month | $160 | $199 |
| 5 creators, a month | $800 | $995 |
| 20 creators, a month | $3,200 | $3,980 |
In a slower month, when the AI sells $500, Hugo's share is $40 while Super AI is $139, because the fixed fee doesn't shrink. The other way round, once AI payout passes $2,380 a month per account (about $2,975 of fan payments), Super AI's lower share makes it the cheaper of the two, as long as the account stays inside its included AI credits. On 26 October 2026 the pricing page showed 10,000 credits a month at its opening band, with extra AI messages at up to 3¢ each. An AI chatter sends many messages per sale, so count them during a trial; our CRM pricing article works through that sum.
Supercreator moves agencies with more than 20 accounts to a custom "Big Agencies" plan, so its 20-creator figure is the list price and a quote may differ. And Super AI includes Supercreator's CRM, while the OnlyX CRM is free on its own.
How each one sells
Izzy sells from a catalog of bundles you build, at least ten of them, through scripts. Each bundle carries a minimum price and an exclusivity level from 1 to 5, and Supercreator says no fan receives a script with content he has already bought.
Hugo picks from the content you have mapped in OnlyX, and the server checks each pick, so he cannot offer a set that doesn't exist. He never re-offers a level a fan already bought, including one a human on your team sold him, and his captions describe only what is in the files. You choose "story", where he climbs your levels in order, or "menu", where he offers whatever level fits what the fan asks for. There are no scripts to write.
On price, Hugo sets one per fan from what that fan has paid before: a first-time buyer usually starts low, a proven buyer pays more, and nobody pays less than your floor. A PPV Hugo sold was unlocked a median 2.8 minutes after he sent it, and 74% within ten minutes (the 30 days to 26 October 2026).
Follow-ups and mass messages
Supercreator has unlimited bumps, an AutoFollower for expired fans, message flows, and a Super Mass Message with AI pricing on Super AI.
Hugo times each follow-up to when that fan is likely to read, sends two a day at most by default (you can set one to four), and stands down the moment the fan or your team writes. An unopened PPV gets one nudge. His mass DMs start conversations and never carry a price; they skip fans who are mid-chat and anyone who said stop recently, and your VIPs can be kept out entirely.
Staying in control
With Izzy you can watch every AI message live and step in, and Izzy flags chats for human review. Supercreator's CRM Premium also offers copilots that suggest messages for a chatter to send, which suits a team that wants a person to approve each line.
In OnlyX, replying to a fan or claiming the chat puts it on manual and keeps Hugo out for 12 hours. For each creator you choose which of about 35 situations, in seven groups, go to your team. Two can never be switched off: any sign a fan is under 18, and self-harm language. AI Rules route the rest, for example "fans who have spent over $1,000 talk to a human". An approve-before-send mode, where a person okays each of Hugo's messages, works through the OnlyX API today and is rolling out to the app.
What each says about OnlyFans' rules
Supercreator's AI chatter page says it "operates within OnlyFans' terms of service", and it recommends being open with fans without requiring it. Our view: OnlyFans has approved no third-party tool, and no tool can guarantee how OnlyFans will act on an account, ours included. What OnlyFans' October 2026 terms say, line by line, is in our article on the new terms. Hugo never claims to be a human, and you can set a fixed AI-identity reply per creator through the OnlyX API.
Which should you pick?
Supercreator may suit you better if
- your chatters already work in its scripts and reports, and retraining has a real cost;
- you want copilots that a chatter approves line by line;
- you run up to 10 accounts and only need its free CRM Lite, without AI;
- your AI sales per account are high and steady, where a fixed fee with a 5% share costs less.
OnlyX may suit you better if
- you want a free CRM for every creator and seat, and to pay for AI only when it sells;
- you don't want to count AI messages or credits;
- you want each fan priced from his own history, never below your floor;
- you run creators on Telegram or Fanvue as well as OnlyFans;
- your fans write in French, Spanish, Portuguese, German or Croatian, whatever the creator's bio says.
According to Supercreator's site, one U.S. agency went from $17K to $27K a day after Izzy took over first replies. We don't publish customer stories like that; judge both on a trial.
How we checked
We read Supercreator's pricing, AI chatter, AI chatter feature, FAQ and testimonial pages on 26 October 2026 (supercreator.app). The fee for the $1,000 to $15,000 band was read with the earnings slider on 11 October 2026. We found no Trustpilot profile for Supercreator, and its GetApp listing had no ratings. We did not sign up for or test Supercreator. Hugo's figures were measured on OnlyX production from OnlyFans' own timestamps, over the windows given. If anything here differs from Supercreator's own page, its page wins; tell us at support@onlyx.ai.
For every other AI chatter we compared, see the best AI chatting software for OnlyFans in 2026. This article is general information, not legal advice. OnlyX is not affiliated with OnlyFans, Fanvue or Supercreator.